To the cloud and back. Why everyone moved to the cloud and why some are now coming back
For ten years the answer to the question of where to keep email, files and software was almost always the same: in the cloud. Today that answer is getting more complicated. Companies are checking their bills, governments are asking who has access to the data, and outages at large providers show the cost of depending on a single place.
Why everyone moved to the cloud
The main reason was financial. Instead of buying a server every few years and spending a large sum from the capital budget, you could pay a small subscription out of operating expenses. After the 2008 crisis, this argument convinced finance directors more than any technology did1.
The second reason was flexibility. In the cloud you pay for what you use, and you can add licences or computing power in minutes, without buying spare hardware2. The third was speed: new tools could be launched in days rather than months.
The pandemic accelerated everything. When staff were sent home overnight, access to email and documents from anywhere became a condition for keeping work going.
What has changed
After a decade of experience, some organisations ran the numbers again. In a Barclays survey of IT directors at the end of 2024, about 83% of respondents planned to move some workloads from the public cloud back in-house or to a private cloud. Some summaries of the survey also cite 86%3. Research firm IDC reports that within a year organisations moved about 18% of applications out of the public cloud4.
An important caveat: almost nobody leaves the cloud completely. Selected elements come back, usually the most expensive to run or the most sensitive, and the rest stays in a hybrid model.
The example the whole industry talks about
37signals, the company behind Basecamp and HEY, moved its applications from Amazon's cloud to its own servers in 2023 without hiring anyone new for the job. It estimates it will save about USD 10 million over five years, and its infrastructure costs fell by half to two thirds5.
In 2025 the company also gave up cloud file storage, for which it was paying close to USD 1.5 million a year. It bought its own storage arrays for about USD 1.5 million, and running them is expected to cost under USD 200,000 a year6.
Buying its own storage arrays cost a one-off approx. USD 1.5M.
Source: The Register, 9 May 2025
Data table
| Item | Annual cost |
|---|---|
| Files in Amazon cloud | approx. USD 1.5M |
| Own storage: running cost | under USD 0.2M |
This is a large technology company with its own team, so a small institution will not reproduce these figures one to one. The mechanism is the same, though: with a steady, predictable workload, owning the hardware is often clearly cheaper than a subscription after a few years.
Who holds the key to the data
The second reason for the shift is not about money. The US CLOUD Act allows US authorities to demand data from American companies even when the data is stored in European data centres. In June 2025 a representative of Microsoft France admitted before the French Senate that the company cannot guarantee that European customers' data will never be handed to US authorities7.
At the same time, the European cloud market is mostly in the hands of three American providers. According to Synergy Research Group, they hold about 70% of the market, while European providers hold about 15%8.
"Others" is the remainder to 100%, calculated by us.
Source: Synergy Research Group, 2025
Data table
| Providers | Share |
|---|---|
| Three largest US providers | approx. 70% |
| European providers | approx. 15% |
| Others | approx. 15% |
Parts of European public administration are already responding. The German state of Schleswig-Holstein is moving its offices from Microsoft products to open-source software: about 40,000 mailboxes have moved from Exchange and Outlook to Open-Xchange and Thunderbird9. In Poland, after the November Microsoft 365 outage, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Digital Affairs Krzysztof Gawkowski spoke about the risk of digital dependence on global companies, and the ministry is preparing a competition for pilot open-source deployments in local government10.
What this means for a public office, school or cultural centre
The point is not to switch the cloud off. The point is a deliberate split: what can stay with a provider and what should remain in the building. Three questions are worth asking:
- Which data is truly sensitive? Data on residents, children, staff and health are the first candidates to keep in-house.
- What happens if the provider or the internet is down for a whole day? If the answer is "we can't do anything", you need a contingency plan.
- How much do we pay every year, and for what? A per-user subscription over five years often exceeds the cost of an on-premises server with support.
Specific options are covered in Cloud, own server or hybrid?, and the new rules for switching providers in From 2027 it gets easier to leave the cloud.
Sources
- Stepping Stones to Cloud, Nutanix
- The history of cloud adoption, G2
- The Great Repatriation: Why Enterprises Are Moving Workloads Back On-Premises, Puppet (summary of the Barclays CIO Survey)
- IDC Survey Spotlight: What Are the Drivers and Impact of Workload Repatriation?, IDC, March 2026
- Cloud exit, 37signals
- 37signals is completing its on-prem move, deleting its AWS account to save millions, The Register, 9 May 2025
- Microsoft admits it 'cannot guarantee' data sovereignty, The Register, 25 July 2025
- European Cloud Providers' Local Market Share Now Holds Steady at 15%, Synergy Research Group
- A small German state's quiet revolt against Microsoft, The Irish Times, 14 February 2026
- Poland says Microsoft outage shows risk of reliance on global tech firms, PAP